CBT guide · Work on a practical obstacle
Structured Problem Solving
Structured problem solving gives a concrete obstacle a name and turns possible responses into a plan. CBT also looks at what the obstacle seems to say about you, because that interpretation can hide options even when the problem itself is real.
Walk through an example
Select each step to see how it works, then try the practice question.
Define the obstacle
State what is happening, what you want instead, and any limits you need to work within. “My schedule is impossible” is less useful than naming the two things that now overlap.
Riley’s work shift now ends after the last bus leaves on Thursday. Riley needs a way home this week without spending more than $15.
Notice what the problem seems to mean
Separate the practical problem from conclusions like “I shouldn’t need help.” Check whether that conclusion is shutting down an option worth considering.
“If I ask my manager, she’ll think I can’t handle the job.” Riley sees that asking once about a scheduling conflict isn’t the same as being unable to do the job.
List and compare options
Name more than one possible response before judging any of them. Compare time, cost, and trade-offs, including which details still need checking.
Ask to start and end earlier, see whether a coworker can share a ride, or check whether another bus route fits. Each option has a detail Riley needs to confirm.
Take one step and review
Choose an option or the first step needed to see if it will work. Decide when you’ll do it and when you’ll check whether you need the next option.
At the next shift, Riley will ask the manager about leaving twenty minutes earlier. If that won’t work, Riley will check the alternate route and ask about a ride by Wednesday.
Which next step makes progress on Riley’s actual problem?
- Ask about the shift change today and choose a backup if the answer is no. This checks a real option while leaving time to arrange another way home. It addresses the shift and bus conflict without needing the worry to disappear first.
- Wait until asking feels comfortable, then decide whether there’s an option. The worry makes sense, but waiting leaves the transportation problem in place. Riley can consider both the worry and the bus schedule without making one depend on the other.
Think through your own situation
You don’t need to enter anything here. Use the prompts on your own.
- What concrete obstacle are you trying to change, and what would be good enough?
- What does the problem seem to say about you? Is that narrowing the options?
- What are two or three options, and what would each cost or require?
- What will you do first, when, and what will tell you to try a different option?
When to use it
Use it when there is a specific problem you can act on, even if you can only change one part of it.
The first useful step may simply be finding out whether an option is available. If the answer is no, use what you learned to choose the next one.
Sources
Based on Judith S. Beck, Problem Solving, CBT Worksheet Packet, pp. 51–53 (Beck Institute). The worked example is original.
