By Tryphtin Scott, MA, LPCC
A church can be where you learned to pray, found friends, served for years, and were hurt by people you trusted. To respond well, we need to ask what actually happened, what we expected, and what is ours to put right. Sometimes that means going to the person we’ve been talking about. Sometimes it means naming serious wrong and bringing it to people who can address it.
When the church isn’t what you hoped it would be
You join a small group expecting close friendships, and months later you still feel like a visitor. A pastor you admire doesn’t have time for the mentoring relationship you hoped for. Those losses can be real without anyone having wronged you. In Life Together, Dietrich Bonhoeffer warns that an idealized picture of Christian community can get in the way of loving the people who are actually there. For Bonhoeffer, Christian community is a gift grounded in Christ, not something we create by getting everyone to live up to our picture of it.
Ask what you hoped for, what the church actually promised, and what was yours to say or do. If a pastor agreed to meet and repeatedly didn’t show up, it’s fair to name the broken commitment. If you hoped the pastor would notice you wanted a mentor but never asked, that hope wasn’t a promise. You can ask directly, invite someone from the group to coffee, or look for a community that can offer what you need. You also don’t have to request basic honesty, respect, or safety to be entitled to them. Owning an unspoken expectation doesn’t make you responsible for someone else’s misuse of power.
When someone actually did wrong
There’s room between ordinary disappointment and abuse. A leader who shares a confidence carelessly may owe you an apology and a change in behavior even if it wasn’t part of a pattern of control. And a church can hold or teach a conviction you disagree with without abusing you. The Church of England’s safeguarding guidance distinguishes having a theological position from using Scripture, office, or fear of disobeying God to control another person.
Pay attention to what happened when you asked a question, said no, or sought outside help. Were you heard, even if you disagreed? Or were you repeatedly threatened with exclusion, told that questioning a leader meant questioning God, or pressed to keep harm secret? A pattern of control matters, but a single serious wrong can still require action.
Take the disagreement to the person
Before you tell the story to anyone else, ask whether you’ve told it fairly to yourself. In Matthew 7:3–5, Jesus tells us to deal with our own fault first so we can see clearly enough to address someone else’s. What did you actually see or hear? What did you infer about their motives? Did you tell them what you expected? If you spoke carelessly, broke your word, or recruited people to your side, own that plainly. You can be right about one part of the conflict and wrong about another.
For ordinary disagreement, start by asking the person rather than announcing what you think they meant. Proverbs 18:17 warns how persuasive one side sounds before the other is heard. You might say: “When the plan changed and I found out from someone else, I assumed I was being pushed out. I should have asked you before I said that to others. What happened from your side?” Then listen long enough for their answer to change your account if it should.
If there is a specific wrong to address, Jesus gives a sequence in Matthew 18:15–17:
- Go to the person privately. Name what they did and give them a chance to hear it, answer, and put it right. If they listen, the aim is to regain your brother or sister, not win a case.
- If they won’t listen, take one or two others. Bring people who can help establish what happened and hear both sides, not friends there to outnumber the other person.
- If they still refuse to listen, bring it to the church. The matter is no longer yours to settle alone. If the person refuses even the church’s correction, Jesus tells the church to treat them as outside its fellowship.
A difference of judgment may remain after a good conversation. That does not make it a disciplinary matter. And where there is abuse, coercion, or a credible threat of retaliation, this passage should not be used to require a private confrontation or to delay reporting. Bring serious allegations to someone with the responsibility and independence to investigate, and to civil authorities when applicable. The Church of England’s safeguarding guidance makes that distinction explicitly.
What repair can and can’t mean
Where it’s safe and the other person is willing to listen, a specific conversation about what happened can be worth having. Serious harm calls for a different response. Christian forgiveness isn’t a reason to keep quiet, excuse what was done, or restore trust on demand. The Church of England’s guidance on pastoral support for survivors warns against invoking forgiveness to silence people or block accountability. An apology matters, but it doesn’t erase the need for accountability or put you under an obligation to return.
The door the Inquisitor opens
In “The Grand Inquisitor,” Book V, chapter 5 of The Brothers Karamazov, Ivan imagines Christ returning to Seville during the Inquisition. The cardinal has him arrested. He says the people are better off surrendering their freedom to men who will decide for them. Christ listens without answering his argument. Then he kisses him. The Inquisitor opens the prison door and tells him never to come back.
The old man does not give up his ideas, and the institution is no less corrupt when the scene ends. But the kiss reaches him anyway, and the door opens. That is the crack I find hopeful. A church can misuse Christ’s name, but it cannot decide where Christ is allowed to go. There may still be room to look for him, and that need not mean walking back through the door of the church that hurt you.
What you can bring to counseling
Start with one moment that stays with you and how it’s affecting your life now. Counseling can help you sort out what happened, what you expected, and whether the next step is a conversation, a boundary, or time to grieve. You can talk about God and Scripture directly or begin with the experience itself. You don’t have to decide where you’ll worship or what you believe before asking for help.
Sources
Scripture: Matthew 18:15–17, Matthew 7:3–5, and Proverbs 18:17 (ESV).
Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Life Together, chapter 1: Community (Fortress Press excerpt)
The Church of England safeguarding guidance: Spiritual Abuse (§4.2)
Fyodor Dostoevsky, The Brothers Karamazov, “The Grand Inquisitor” (Constance Garnett translation)

