By Tryphtin Scott, MA, LPCC
After someone dies, it can be difficult to remember the prayers you offered while they were alive. You may remember asking God for a treatment to work, for more time, or simply for the chance to have another conversation. At the time, praying gave you somewhere to bring your fear. Now, trying to pray can bring you back to the moment you were still waiting for news, before you knew how the story would end.
What makes prayer difficult in that moment may be more specific than a general loss of faith. You may still believe that God hears you and find yourself reluctant to ask him for anything. Another person’s invitation to pray may feel comforting one day and unbearable the next. A familiar prayer can carry the memory of the people who said it with you, the hope you felt as you said it, and what it cost to hope that much.
What happens when you try to pray?
In A Grief Observed, C.S. Lewis writes about the death of his wife and the sense of finding God inaccessible precisely when he most wanted to turn to him. Lewis’s description is worth reading as a record of what loss felt like to him. It gives particular attention to the disorientation of addressing someone who once seemed near and now seems silent.
Your experience may be different. You might want to pray and find that you can’t get past the first words. You might be angry at God, or at the people who encouraged you to believe the person would recover. You might still pray for other people with ease and feel a resistance you can’t explain when you try to pray about your own loss. It can help to notice where that resistance appears. Does it come when you think about asking God for something? When you hear a phrase you remember from the hospital? When someone assumes that prayer feels reassuring to you?
These questions can bring into view something that a general instruction to pray more would miss. You may be trying to understand what to do with a particular memory, or how to trust someone enough to say aloud what you now feel toward God.
Let someone hear what is difficult
In The Deepest Place, Curt Thompson considers how hope is formed in relationships in the midst of suffering. Applied to prayer after loss, that raises a practical question: Who could hear about the prayers you remember without trying to explain why they weren’t answered in the way you hoped?
A person who can do that may be able to listen as you tell them what you asked for, what you expected, and what you find difficult to say now. You might want them to pray with you, to pray for you privately, or to sit with you without praying at all. It is reasonable to be specific about what would help: “I’d like to tell you what I remember from that week. Can you listen without trying to help me make sense of it yet?”
If you want to pray but ordinary words feel out of reach, you could begin with something as particular as, “God, I remember asking you to let her live, and I don’t know what to say to you now.” You can leave the prayer there. You may also find that what you want to do that day is tell someone about the person who died, or sit quietly with them. There is no need to measure what that moment accomplished before it ends.
Bringing the question into counseling
In grief counseling, we can talk through what happened and what it has been like to live with the absence since. If prayer has become difficult, we can pay attention to what it brings up, including what you remember asking for and how people responded when you spoke about the loss. The conversation can include questions about God if you want it to. You can also ask to talk about the effect of the loss on your faith without including prayer in the session.
The prayers you offered before the death are part of the story of how much you wanted that person to live. If they are painful to remember now, they deserve to be heard with that care.

